![](https://www.uscancelclub.org/wp-content/uploads/NY-Dalton-1886-03-10-300x196.jpeg)
![](https://www.uscancelclub.org/wp-content/uploads/MN-Heron-Dalton-Ny-1886-03-07.jpeg-300x197.jpeg)
The cancel looks similar to this attached Cole (GE-130) cancel.
Answer: I think the Cole cancel is your cancel, but perhaps from a worn handstamp or one where there was some inking or strike deficiency. Attached is a scan from Whitfield that shows, at the top, quite a detailed strike of the cancel (1732).